Today we are excited to launch the Open Data Release Toolkit to help you manage the release of sensitive or protected datasets on the open data portal.
Challenge: following the letter of the law is not enough
While privacy laws state how to protect data, most of them were written well before modern computing and statistical tools. These tools challenge the idea of simple de-identification of data. For example, you could publish record level data on probationers without obvious identifiers, such as names and social security numbers, and still be within the law. But by combining that data with other sources or just doing some crosstabs, you might be able to identify the individuals in the dataset and associated sensitive or personal information about them. As a result, open data programs need a much more robust way of managing the release of sensitive or protected datasets.
That sounds scary, so why still publish?
Sensitive or protected raw data is a lot like the information you carry around in your wallet. There will always be a risk, no matter how infinitely small, that someone is going to steal your wallet. (Even if you are a vigilant city dweller who securely tucks it away.) So why do we carry some of our most sensitive information around with us? Because we value the activities we can engage in - going to a bar with our ID card, purchasing lunch with our credit card, keeping our medical information to hand in case of emergency, etc.
Substitute that card in your wallet for sensitive or protected data, such as a person’s identity or sensitive information about them. Just like most people still find reasons to carry around a wallet, our open data program aims to proactively make data available for the public benefit. Open data can help us to, among other things, measure the effectiveness of government services; stimulate new ideas and services; identify communities in need of better assistance; and ultimately change how we use, share and consume data to work more efficiently and effectively.
Responsible risk management
Like a vigilant tourist who purchases the best money-belt on the market before a trip, we seek to publish data responsibly. This requires a balancing of competing factors such as:
- the value of publishing the data,
- an individual’s expectation of privacy,
- repercussions to an individual or the organization from re-identification, and
- the likelihood of re-identification.
Sound tricky? It is. Especially when you pile on top ever-evolving data analysis and re-identification techniques. That is why we created this handy Toolkit! To provide practical, clear guidance for government employees considering publication of sensitive or protected raw data.
The Open Data Release Toolkit will guide you through a step-by-step process to:
- Identify sensitive or protected raw data,
- Perform a risk assessment regarding the identifiability of the data,
- Choose and implement privacy solutions (e.g. de-identification methods), and
- Perform a risk assessment regarding the accessibility of the de-identified data.
Remember - risk can be managed, but it will not be zero
We can never have absolute certainty (i.e. zero risk) that successful re-identification will not occur. Techniques for re-identification continually evolve, often faster than security measures intended to protect data. While re-identification risk will never be 0%, it can be reduced and managed. Acknowledging the supposed failures of “perfect anonymization”, the Open Data Release Toolkit moves forward by setting out a decision-making process to publish valuable information while managing risk of re-identification and sensitive attribute disclosure in a thoughtful way.
A huge thanks to the authors and partners mentioned in the Acknowledgements and Resources section of the detailed guide, from whom we learned a great deal. Even with this learning, we know the field is evolving and we do not have all the answers. We are keeping our eyes on the recent draft from NIST on De-Identifying Government Datasets, and we welcome any feedback!
Check out the Open Data Release Toolkit!